Landscape Designer or Gardener: Which Professional Is Right for Your Project?
One of the most common questions I receive is: Do we need a landscape designer or a gardener for our project? If you're planning a landscape transformation, it’s important to understand the distinction between these two roles. In this post, I’ll help you decide which professional is the best fit for your needs.
What’s the Difference Between a Landscape Designer and a Gardener?
The roles of landscape designer and gardener are often confused, as many professionals wear both hats. While a teacher or pilot’s role is clearly defined, the landscape industry encompasses various specialties, leaving some people unsure about whether they need a designer or gardener.
Some landscape professionals provide both design and maintenance services, while others focus exclusively on one area. So, how do you choose the right person for your specific project?
What Does a Landscape Designer Do?
A landscape designer is someone you hire when you want to create a cohesive plan for your outdoor space. When you work with a landscape designer, you’re starting a collaborative relationship to bring your landscape vision to life. Designers interpret your ideas and transform them into detailed, functional design plans for contractors to implement.
Key responsibilities of a landscape designer include:
Creating Detailed Plans: Designers provide technical drawings, scaled layouts, plant lists, and mood boards, all aimed at helping you visualize your space before installation.
Solving Space and Layout Issues: Designers excel at overcoming challenges related to plant placement, privacy, and materials, ensuring your space is both functional and aesthetically pleasing.
Budget-Friendly Solutions: A good landscape designer will work with your budget to create a design that fits your financial constraints while still delivering beauty and function.
Hi, I’m Jenn. I am a trained landscape designer and horticulture technician who loves to learn and talk about plants! I am the driving force behind Jennifer Sleigh Garden Design, a custom landscape design company that provides services in Greater Victoria.
Follow along for gardening tips and exciting project updates!
A 3d model to help visualize a new back patio and garden. 3d models can solve crucial space challenges while giving clients a realistic view of their future space.
Designers have been trained in horticulture and design
A landscape designer’s training typically includes both horticulture and design principles, often resulting in a diploma or degree in landscape design. This expertise allows them to address complex design issues, from layout challenges to plant selection, while ensuring that the final design is practical and sustainable.
Quick black and white drawings help clients visualize the potential of the design.
What Does a Gardener Do?
On the other hand, a gardener is someone who carries out the physical work of installing and maintaining a garden. Gardeners often have formal training in horticulture or have gained experience through hands-on work or mentoring. Depending on their skill level, gardeners can:
Implement Designs: Gardeners can bring landscape design plans to life, working with contractors or independently to install plants, paths, and other features.
Maintain and Care for Gardens: Gardeners focus on the upkeep of your garden, including weeding, pruning, seasonal planting, and soil care.
Offer Design Services (In Some Cases): Some gardeners have a good eye for design and can create smaller-scale garden plans directly on-site, without formal drawings. If you’re lucky enough to find one with both a creative vision and horticultural skills, they can offer a personalized approach to your garden.
While gardeners typically focus on maintenance and installation, some can also design smaller spaces. The key is finding a gardener who understands the balance between aesthetics and horticulture.
A planting plan for a sunny site. This technical drawing shows where to plant each individual plant which is represented by a coloured circle.
When to Hire a Landscape Designer vs. a Gardener
Both professionals play important roles in transforming and maintaining outdoor spaces. Here’s when you should consider hiring one over the other:
Hire a Landscape Designer if:
You need a comprehensive, long-term plan for your space, with specific design elements and materials.
You have complex design issues or need expert advice on layout, plant selection, and functionality.
You’re looking for detailed plans (e.g., technical drawings, plant lists, and construction specifications) that will guide your project from concept to completion.
Hire a Gardener if:
You want ongoing garden maintenance (e.g., weeding, pruning, seasonal planting).
You prefer incremental changes to your landscape, such as refreshing planting beds or adding new features gradually.
Your budget is limited, or you only need help with planting and basic landscape installation.
You need assistance with small projects like adding a path or garden features, or you already have a basic design in mind.
Planting day is always exciting for everyone!
The Importance of the Right Professional for Your Project
Ultimately, whether you choose a landscape designer or gardener depends on your project’s scope and needs. Some designers will remain involved throughout the installation, while others may only provide design plans for you or a contractor to execute. Likewise, some gardeners may offer design services for smaller projects, but they primarily focus on planting and maintenance.
The key to a successful project lies in the relationship between you and the professional you hire. Do your research, ask for recommendations, and choose someone whose skills align with your vision.
Creating a garden involves both art and science, and finding the right professional is the first step toward bringing your dream landscape to life. I hope this post helps clear up the roles of landscape designers and gardeners, so you can make an informed decision for your project!
